Class 9: Accommodating Worker Lives – Work-Life Balance Laws
Summary of Core Topics: Class 9 shifts focus to laws that help employees balance their work with personal life obligations and health needs – in other words, accommodation and leave laws. Central to this discussion is the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), a federal law requiring covered employers (50+ employees) to provide eligible workers up to 12 weeks of unpaid, job-protected leave for certain family and medical reasons (such as an employee’s serious health condition, a new baby, or care of a spouse/child/parent with a serious health issue). We examine who is eligible under FMLA (at least 12 months tenure, 1,250 hours, and employer 50+ employees within 75 miles) and what rights it gives – continuation of health benefits during leave and restoration to the same or equivalent job on return. We also look at reasonable accommodations for disabilities under the ADA: unlike FMLA’s fixed leave, the ADA (for employers 15+ employees) requires employers to make individualized accommodations for an employee’s disability, which could include modified duties, schedule changes, or even leave beyond FMLA if it doesn’t pose undue hardship. Similarly, pregnancy accommodations are highlighted: historically, the Pregnancy Discrimination Act required pregnant workers be treated the same as others similar in ability to work, but now laws mandate more – e.g., the new federal Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA) of 2023 requires reasonable accommodations for pregnancy and related conditions (pregnancy is not an ADA disability, but now gets similar accommodation rights under PWFA). Illinois was ahead here – since 2015, Illinois law has required employers to accommodate pregnant employees (providing things like light duty, more breaks, etc., absent undue hardship). The class also covers religious accommodations under Title VII – employers must accommodate employees’ sincerely held religious practices (like schedule changes for Sabbath observance or dress/grooming exemptions) unless it poses an undue hardship. We then turn to Illinois-specific leave laws that supplement federal law: for instance, the new Illinois Paid Leave for All Workers Act effective 2024, which requires most Illinois employers to provide up to 40 hours of paid leave per year that can be used for any reason; the Victims’ Economic Security and Safety Act (VESSA), giving victims of domestic violence or sexual violence (or family members) up to 12 weeks unpaid leave for related matters; the School Visitation Rights Act, allowing parents limited time off to attend school conferences if they have no other PTO; and the Family Bereavement Leave Act, which in Illinois now provides 10 days of leave for events like the death of a family member or pregnancy loss (applicable to FMLA-covered employers). We discuss how these state provisions fill gaps (for example, FMLA doesn’t cover small employers, but Illinois’ paid leave law covers essentially all employers; FMLA doesn’t cover non-medical personal needs, but Illinois paid leave does for a small amount of time).
The class also delves into “work-life” accommodations like flexible scheduling and remote work – not a legal right generally, but something increasingly negotiated, and how the pandemic influenced this. Students consider both employer and employee perspectives on managing time off and flexibility, and learn the concept of undue hardship as the limit on accommodation (significant expense or operational difficulty). By class end, they should understand the patchwork of laws that enable employees to take care of their health and family without losing their job, and how these laws reflect a policy balance between employee well-being and business needs.
Drafting Assignment: For an employer, draft a section of a handbook addressing overtime compensation.
Read
Hypothetical 1: Carlos works at a Chicago company with 100 employees. He requests time off under FMLA to care for his mother after major surgery. He has been full-time for 3 years. His boss is hesitant, saying “we really need you – can’t someone else do it?” and suggests Carlos take only 2 weeks instead of the 6 weeks he asked for. What are Carlos’s rights under FMLA?
Model Answer: Carlos is eligible for FMLA (the company has 100 employees, he’s worked 12+ months and 1,250+ hours). Caring for a parent after surgery qualifies as a serious health condition (if it involves inpatient care or continuing treatment). Under FMLA, Carlos is entitled to up to 12 weeks of unpaid leave in a 12-month period for this purpose. His boss’s suggestion to limit to 2 weeks is not permissible if 6 weeks are medically necessary – the employer cannot arbitrarily cap the leave below 12 weeks. They also cannot deny the leave due to workload needs – FMLA is a right, not discretionary once eligibility and qualifying reason are met. The boss’s hesitation could be viewed as interference with FMLA rights if he tries to block or discourage Carlos from taking the full leave. Carlos should provide any required medical certification from his mother’s doctor indicating the need for 6 weeks of care. In Illinois, aside from FMLA, Carlos could also use some of his 40 hours of paid leave under the new state law for this purpose if he wanted to be paid for one week, but the key is FMLA gives him job-protected time off. So, Carlos has the right to take up to 6 weeks (or even 12 if needed) and should not be retaliated against or pressured to cut it short.
Hypothetical 2: Darius is a truck driver whose religion prohibits working from Friday sundown to Saturday sundown (Sabbath). His employer schedules him for some Saturday routes. He requests a schedule change to have Saturdays off. How should the employer handle this request after Groff v. DeJoy (2023)?
Model Answer: Darius is seeking a religious accommodation under Title VII – having Saturdays off for Sabbath observance. Following Groff v. DeJoy, the employer must accommodate unless doing so would cause an undue hardship meaning substantial increased costs or substantial disruption to the business. In the past, some courts allowed employers to deny such requests by citing minimal cost or coworker resentment as “more than de minimis” hardship. Post-Groff, that standard is higher: the employer should attempt to rearrange schedules (have other drivers cover Saturdays) and cannot deny just because it’s inconvenient or might require paying a bit of overtime. The employer should assess how many Saturday routes need coverage, whether others can swap (voluntarily or via an incentive) and if any cost incurred (like paying overtime to another driver occasionally) is a substantial expense. Likely, giving Darius Saturdays off is not an undue hardship if the company can manage coverage – e.g., if other drivers are willing to swap or if an extra temp driver can cover. The Groff decision specifically noted that impacts on coworkers must also affect the business’s operations to count as undue hardship – so just complaining by coworkers isn’t enough. If the company has a thin crew and literally no way to cover Saturdays without, say, hiring another driver at significant cost or leaving deliveries unmet (a “substantial” burden), they’d document that. But many times, accommodations like this can be done (perhaps Darius covers more Sunday or Monday shifts in exchange). So under the new standard, the employer should likely grant the request unless it can show concrete significant difficulties (and it should document efforts made). Under Illinois law, Darius is also protected (IHRA includes religion and similar accommodation duty). In sum, the employer should treat this similar to ADA: engage with Darius, find a workable solution like swapping shifts, and only if that truly undermines operations could they refuse. The change in law from Groff means employers need to be more flexible with such requests than some may have been previously.
Employer Perspective: Employers often find leave and accommodation laws challenging because they require flexibility and can strain operations. From an employer’s perspective, key strategies include developing clear leave policies that incorporate all applicable laws (FMLA, state paid leave, etc.) and training HR and managers to recognize accommodation requests even if an employee doesn’t use magic words. For instance, if someone says “I’m having trouble with the lifting tasks due to my back,” that’s effectively a request for accommodation – under ADA and Illinois law, the employer should start an interactive process. Good employers create a culture where employees feel comfortable disclosing needs – which helps prevent small issues from becoming crises. Employers should also plan for coverage during absences: cross-training staff or hiring temporary replacements for FMLA leaves. Yes, a 12-week absence can be disruptive, but advanced planning mitigates that. Many employers use software or HRIS tools to track FMLA usage and ensure they don’t mistakenly count FMLA absences as unexcused. Under Illinois’s new paid leave, employers will adjust by perhaps frontloading 40 hours or tracking accrual (the law allows either. For accommodations, employers should remember that providing an accommodation is usually far cheaper than facing a lawsuit or losing a good employee. Many accommodations (like schedule tweaks or ergonomic equipment) are low cost. Even something like allowing remote work – as long as productivity stays up – can be a win-win. The employer’s right is to deny accommodations that truly cause undue hardship, but that threshold is higher than some think. A wise employer will carefully assess hardship – maybe consult an attorney – before saying no. Also, employers must be mindful of privacy and consistency: handle medical info confidentially and apply leave policies consistently to avoid discrimination claims (e.g., don’t favor one group with flexible arrangements but not another without a valid reason). Communication is key: if an employee is out on FMLA, stay in gentle contact (e.g., “We hope your mother’s recovery is going well. Let us know if you need the full 6 weeks or more”) without pressuring early return. Planning the return-to-work is equally important – under FMLA, you generally must restore the same or equivalent position, so have that lined up. Some employers offer return-to-work programs to help employees transition back after long leaves (like part-time ramp-up, though not required, it’s a goodwill gesture). And with overlapping laws, compliance can be tricky – e.g., an employee’s situation might invoke FMLA, ADA, and IHRA pregnancy law simultaneously (consider a pregnant employee with complications: she might use FMLA, need ADA accommodation of reduced hours, and be protected by pregnancy accommodation law). Employers should look at all applicable laws in such scenarios and default to the most employee-favorable provisions to be safe. Finally, consider creativity and goodwill: Many companies now voluntarily go beyond the minimum (like offering paid parental leave, or flexible scheduling options) to attract and retain talent. While not legally required, such benefits can reduce turnover and increase morale – important employer goals. In summary, from an employer’s view, compliance is not just a legal duty but also an opportunity to show you value employees as whole people – which in turn can enhance the company’s reputation and productivity.
Employee Perspective: For employees, knowing these leave and accommodation rights is empowering. Too often, employees don’t take advantage of FMLA or state leave out of fear or ignorance. From the employee’s side: if you or a family member has a serious health issue, or you have a new baby, educate yourself on FMLA. If you’re eligible, you have the right to take leave and not be fired for it. Give your employer notice (30 days in advance for foreseeable leave like a scheduled surgery or due date; as soon as practicable for emergencies). You usually need to provide a medical certification – do that on time to protect your leave. While FMLA is unpaid, plan financially if you can (some supplement with vacation time or short-term disability insurance if it’s their own medical leave).
Practical Tips and Takeaways:
- Plan Leave Ahead: Employees, if you know you will need time off (for a planned surgery, maternity leave, etc.), give your employer as much notice as possible and communicate a plan for how work can be handled in your absence. Employers appreciate this and are less likely to resent the leave. Employers, when you receive a notice of leave, respond with the required FMLA eligibility notice promptly and begin planning for coverage – possibly redistribute duties temporarily or hire a temp.
- Intermittent Leave Management: Both sides should understand intermittent FMLA. Employees should try to schedule predictable treatments (if possible) in coordination with work and keep the employer informed of their likely frequency/duration of flare-ups. Employers should ensure managers know that intermittent leave, even on short notice, is protected – no disciplining for those absences. Use timesheets or leave codes to track FMLA hours separately from regular sick days to avoid confusion.
- Accommodation Brainstorm: Engage in good faith interactive process. Employers should listen to the employee’s needs and brainstorm accommodations (maybe involve a third-party expert or use Job Accommodation Network (JAN) resources for ideas). Document this process – it shows you took it seriously. Employees should be open about their limitations and, if comfortable, educate the employer about their condition’s impacts (without oversharing medical details beyond necessary). If an employer offers something, give it a try unless it’s plainly unworkable – success could surprise you, and if it fails, you can adjust later.
- Avoiding Stereotypes: Employers, be careful not to make paternalistic decisions like assuming a pregnant worker can’t do a job or that a disabled employee is “better off on leave.” Let the employee signal their limits and needs. The law requires an individualized assessment, not assumptions. For instance, don’t move someone off a project because “I figured you’d want to rest due to pregnancy” – that could be discrimination if done without her asking.
- Documentation and Medical Certs: Employees, provide required documentation: FMLA medical certs within 15 days, doctors’ notes if requested (and reasonable) for accommodations. Employers, keep medical info confidential and only ask for what’s needed. For ADA, you can ask for a note confirming the employee has a covered disability and needs the accommodation, but not for their entire medical history. In Illinois pregnancy accommodation, interestingly, the law says employers cannot require an employee to provide a doctor’s note for accommodation unless it’s a request for transfer or heavy lifting exemption, etc. (Illinois took a worker-friendly approach there). Know these nuances.
- Work-Life Culture: On a broader level, both employers and employees benefit from a culture that respects work-life balance. Encouraging employees to actually use their leave (vacation, paid leave, etc.) prevents burnout and can make them more productive long-term. For example, Illinois’ new paid leave – employers shouldn’t unofficially pressure staff not to take it; that undermines the law and morale. Embrace it: celebrate that your team has this new benefit and plan so people taking time off doesn’t halt operations. For employees, taking your entitled leave (and unplugging if possible) can improve your health and job performance. These laws exist because society recognizes no one should have to sacrifice their family or health on the altar of work. Class 9’s takeaway is that a successful workplace is one where business needs and human needs are balanced – and the law is increasingly nudging employers to find that balance.
